Holiday Vault: Engagement Rings

The Vault is open — new pieces added weekly

One-of-a-kind fine jewelry from our Williamsville showroom — single pieces, most of which never made it online until now. There is exactly one of each. When a piece sells, it is gone.

Behind the Showcase

“Every piece in the Vault is one we chose, photographed and had in the case. Some are designer samples, some are pieces a customer never came back for. They are all real, all here, and there is only ever one.”

Vault pricing is live right now, and we are adding pieces every week through November 20. Anything you see is ready to buy or reserve today — our Sparkle Associates can set a piece aside for you, but with one of each, first come really is first served.

Shop the Vault by category

Engagement Rings14 pieces Wedding & Anniversary Bands2 pieces Diamond Studs10 pieces Fashion Rings1 piece Bracelets2 pieces Moissanite6 pieces Gifts10 pieces

What to know before you shop

  • One of each. Every listing is a single piece in our Williamsville case — no restocks, no second one in another size.
  • Try it on. Everything here is physically in the store at 5001 Transit Road, Williamsville, NY. Call (716) 631-1584 to have a piece ready when you arrive.
  • Engagement settings. Most bridal pieces are settings — choose a natural or lab-grown center with us and your ring arrives fully assembled, with the setting crafted for your stone.
  • Sizing and service. Sizing, cleaning and inspection are handled by our own goldsmiths at the bench, not shipped out.
  • In-store only bin. A large group of smaller Vault pieces never gets photographed — they are priced flat and sold in the showroom only, so it is worth the drive.

Ben Garelick has been Buffalo's family-owned jeweler since 1952, with more than 1,350 five-star reviews. The Vault is how we make room for what comes next.