Custom Engagement Rings

Why Ben Garelick?

We've been a family name in Buffalo since 1952 — starting as a downtown jewelry wholesaler and growing into one of the region's most trusted jewelers at our Transit Road showroom in Williamsville. Three generations later, what makes us us hasn't changed: we treat every customer like family.

Our team takes the time to get to know you, your style, and your story. We'll walk you through everything — diamonds, gemstones, metals, settings — so you feel confident and excited, never pressured. With world-class bridal designers like Simon G., Gabriel & Co., Noam Carver, and Bleu Royale in our collection, you'll find something that feels like it was made for you.

Engagement rings are at the heart of what we do. We keep a wide selection of styles in our showroom and love helping you find — or create — the ring that tells your love story.

Our 3D Ring Designer gives you the best of both worlds: the creative freedom of a fully custom design with the speed and value you want. Build your ring around your center stone, see it come to life in 3D, and have it in your hands in just a couple of weeks. Start designing online or come see us in person at our Williamsville showroom — and when you've found a design you love, schedule an appointment so we can help you choose the perfect diamond and put the finishing touches on your ring.