• Making Your
    Engagement Extra Special

Making Your
Engagement Extra Special

Explore our Collection
  • Making Your
    Engagement Extra Special

Making Your
Engagement Extra Special

Explore our Collection

Bestsellers

Planning on getting married? You’ll find an impressive selection of unique diamond engagement rings and wedding bands online and in our Buffalo, New York area showroom. For more than 65 years, Ben Garelick has provided the perfect engagement ring to make that important question the most memorable experience possible. Our combination of impressive selection, quality, and knowledgeable jewelers make Ben Garelick the best choice for choosing your engagement and wedding rings.

  • Ben Garelick Compass Set Princess Cut Starlight Engagement Ring
    Ben Garelick Compass Set Princess Cut Starlight Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $1,750.00
    Sale price
    $1,750.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ben Garelick Princess Cut Compass Set Moonglow Diamond Engagement Ring
    Ben Garelick Princess Cut Compass Set Moonglow Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $1,075.00
    Sale price
    $1,075.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ben Garelick Round Cut Orion Diamond Engagement Ring
    Ben Garelick Round Cut Orion Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $1,500.00
    Sale price
    $1,500.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ben Garelick Astra Galactic Head Diamond Engagement Ring
    Ben Garelick Astra Galactic Head Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $1,475.00
    Sale price
    $1,475.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver 14K White Gold Emerald Cut High Polish Solitaire Engagement Ring
    Noam Carver 14K White Gold Emerald Cut High Polish Solitaire Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $1,025.00
    Sale price
    $1,025.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver 14K White Gold Hidden Halo Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
    Noam Carver 14K White Gold Hidden Halo Emerald Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $2,250.00
    Sale price
    $2,250.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Oval Cut Solitaire Two-Tone Rose & White Gold Engagement Ring with a High Polish Finish and White Gold Head.
    Noam Carver Oval Cut Solitaire Two-Tone Rose & White Gold Engagement Ring with a High Polish Finish and White Gold Head.

    Regular price
    $925.00
    Sale price
    $925.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ben Garelick Astra Galactic Head Round Diamond Engagement Ring
    Ben Garelick Astra Galactic Head Round Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $1,475.00
    Sale price
    $1,475.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Rose & White Round Cut Twist Diamond Engagement Ring
    Noam Carver Rose & White Round Cut Twist Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $1,750.00
    Sale price
    $1,750.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Two-Tone Yellow Gold High Polish Round Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring with White Gold Head
    Noam Carver Two-Tone Yellow Gold High Polish Round Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring with White Gold Head

    Regular price
    $1,025.00
    Sale price
    $1,025.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Two-Tone Yellow Gold High Polish Cushion Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring with White Gold Four Claw Prong Head
    Noam Carver Two-Tone Yellow Gold High Polish Cushion Cut Solitaire Engagement Ring with White Gold Four Claw Prong Head

    Regular price
    $1,025.00
    Sale price
    $1,025.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Gabriel Amavida Chelsea Diamond Engagement Ring
    Gabriel Amavida Chelsea Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $1,725.00
    Sale price
    $1,725.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Ben Garelick Elongated Radiant Diamond Engagement Ring
    Ben Garelick Elongated Radiant Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $2,250.00
    Sale price
    $2,250.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver 14K Yellow Gold Hidden Halo French Set Diamond Engagement Ring
    Noam Carver 14K Yellow Gold Hidden Halo French Set Diamond Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $2,200.00
    Sale price
    $2,200.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Simon G. Round Cut Supernova Diamond Baguette Halo Engagement Ring
    Simon G. Round Cut Supernova Diamond Baguette Halo Engagement Ring

    Regular price
    $4,910.00
    Sale price
    $4,910.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Nature Inspired Vine Stackable Band
    Noam Carver Nature Inspired Vine Stackable Band

    Regular price
    $1,125.00
    Sale price
    $1,125.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Bleu Royale 8mm Tantalum & Beveled Edges Wedding Band
    Bleu Royale 8mm Tantalum & Beveled Edges Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $1,975.00
    Sale price
    $1,975.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Vintage Style Wedding Band with Milgrain Details
    Noam Carver Vintage Style Wedding Band with Milgrain Details

    Regular price
    $1,250.00
    Sale price
    $1,250.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Marquise Tip
    Noam Carver Marquise Tip

    Regular price
    $1,450.00
    Sale price
    $1,450.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Bleu Royale Grey Sandpaper Finish Tantalum Wedding Band
    Bleu Royale Grey Sandpaper Finish Tantalum Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $1,375.00
    Sale price
    $1,375.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Shared Prong Diamond Wedding Band
    Noam Carver Shared Prong Diamond Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $1,900.00
    Sale price
    $1,900.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Bleu Royale Black Carbon & Beveled Edge Wedding Band
    Bleu Royale Black Carbon & Beveled Edge Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $1,775.00
    Sale price
    $1,775.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Crown Diamond Scalloped Stackable Band
    Noam Carver Crown Diamond Scalloped Stackable Band

    Regular price
    $3,375.00
    Sale price
    $3,375.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Bleu Royale Frosted Grey Tantalum Rose Gold Wedding Band
    Bleu Royale Frosted Grey Tantalum Rose Gold Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $1,250.00
    Sale price
    $1,250.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Marquise Cut Flair Diamond Stackable Ring
    Noam Carver Marquise Cut Flair Diamond Stackable Ring

    Regular price
    $1,915.00
    Sale price
    $1,915.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Interwoven Twist Diamond Stackable Band
    Noam Carver Interwoven Twist Diamond Stackable Band

    Regular price
    $2,500.00
    Sale price
    $2,500.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • CrownRing 6MM Two-Tone Patterned Wedding Band
    CrownRing 6MM Two-Tone Patterned Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $875.00
    Sale price
    $875.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Noam Carver Round Cut Criss-Cross Diamond Wedding Band
    Noam Carver Round Cut Criss-Cross Diamond Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $1,425.00
    Sale price
    $1,425.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • CrownRing Torque Black & White Cobalt Wedding Band
    CrownRing Torque Black & White Cobalt Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $365.00
    Sale price
    $365.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out
  • Bleu Royale Black Carbon & Rope Texture Wedding Band
    Bleu Royale Black Carbon & Rope Texture Wedding Band

    Regular price
    $1,790.00
    Sale price
    $1,790.00
    ar price
    price
    per 
    Sold out

Our Heritage & Mission

Book Some Time to Sparkle

From Our Customers

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐The ring is simply Magical!

David & Keira

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely breathtaking. So simple but so beautiful. Exactly what I dreamed of!

Courtney & Austin

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ This is going to make Caitlin the happiest girl in the world! The engagement ring looks like it completes her hand!

Alex & Caitlin

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely stunning. I couldn't have picked out a better ring than he did. I still can't stop staring at it.

Lizzie & Marc

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely gorgeous, very unique. I've never seen one this style before. She gets compliments all the time and people make comments that her husband must be loaded haha. I wish, just a fanfriggntastic jeweler.

Orianna & Rory

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ It’s a unique Kirk Kara that Peter helped pick out. It’s the antique Angelique collection, with a custom-fit Oval 1.5 ct. stone, and has the most intricate swirls of diamonds and gold that I couldn’t want any more!

Taylor & Justin

"Our first date was a warm, sunny Sunday in October. The day started with brunch followed by apple picking at Becker Farms. After the first date, the rest was history!"

Joe & Liz

Free Gift Wrapping

Ben Garelick will gift wrap your purchase free of charge beautifully wrapped and tied with a luxurious blue ribbon. Boxes included on all orders.