Free Shipping on All Orders over $200

Welcome to Ben Garelick Jewelers - Buffalo’s premier fine jeweler

Whether you want to express your affection with a gemstone necklace, or you are ready to profess true love with the perfect pink sapphire and diamond engagement ring, she’ll cry the good kind of tears with a gift from Ben Garelick Jewelers. For more than 60 years, we’ve been New York’s best jewelry store with a unique selection of high-quality jewelry and professional, knowledgeable jewelers to assist you in every way.

Say “Yes” To Our Extensive Diamond Selection

At Ben Garelick Jewelers, we understand that with individual personalities, every person is going to have a unique picture of their perfect diamond engagement ring. That’s why we offer so many diamond cuts and styles. Round & oval-shaped diamonds, cushion cut halo settings, and bypass twist engagement rings are a few of our customer’s favorites. From antique and vintage to unique and contemporary, Ben Garelick will have a ring that suits your wishes, desires, and budget. This representation of your true love will have your bride-to-be saying “yes” to that most important question.

More Than Just Diamonds

Not only does Ben Garelick offer the most spectacular array of sparkling diamonds, we offer a variety of gemstones, alone and in combination with diamonds. Our blue sapphire or amethyst and diamond engagement rings offer a beautifully unique alternative to the traditional all-diamond ring. And you’ll look stunning in any of the following jewelry items created by our Ben Garelick designers or other designers showcased in our Buffalo, NY jewelry store:

Knowledgeable Diamond Experts

Buying a diamond ring shouldn’t be frightening. Our expert Ben Garelick jewelers are ready to ensure that you find the perfect ring with the most sparkling diamonds or gemstones. Our jewelry designers can help customize any engagement or anniversary ring, or any piece of jewelry that needs small changes to make it perfect. They will answer your questions and help you understand the options that you have in selecting your perfect engagement ring. Providing our discerning customers with the best customer service, free cleanings and a lifetime diamond trade-up is why Ben Garelick Jewelers has been the best jeweler in Buffalo for decades.

Browse Our Selection Online Or In Our Showroom

Find your unforgettable diamond engagement ring or wedding band at Ben Garelick. Whether you shop online or at our Buffalo, New York showroom, we’ll guide you through our stunning collection of fine jewelry designs until you settle on the perfect piece. Chat with our experts live online, contact us through our online form, or call us at (716) 631-1584. We look forward to you joining our family of diamond experts as we assist you in finding the diamond you love for the one you love.