Engagement Rings

Planning to propose? You’ll find an impressive selection of unique diamond engagement rings online and in our Buffalo, New York area showroom. For more than 70 years, Ben Garelick Jewelers has provided the perfect engagement ring to make that important question the most memorable experience possible. Our combination of impressive selection, quality, and knowledgeable jewelers make Ben Garelick the best choice for choosing your engagement and wedding rings.

At Ben Garelick Jewelers, you’ll find hundreds of unique styles that will fit every person’s dream. From vintage style engagement rings to 3-carat diamond solitaires, our Buffalo jewelry store will have what you are looking for. We proudly carry Simon G., Gabriel & Co. and Noam Carver styles that will inspire you. White gold princess cut diamond rings, diamond solitaires, twisted diamond rings, and vintage halo rings are some of the most popular engagement rings our customers ask for and we have them all! And we can match a diamond wedding band or other unique ring to perfectly accompany your engagement ring. All of our diamonds are hand-selected and offer outstanding cuts for the best sparkle.

Ben Garelick Jewelers makes it easy to get started with your engagement ring selection process. Visit our Buffalo, NY, jewelry store to see our selection in person and meet with one of our expert jewelers about the diamond engagement ring you are looking for. Every customer at Ben Garelick is special; it is only natural that Ben Garelick has extended this philosophy to our online store, BenGarelick.com. Here you browse our huge selection or chat online with one of our service representatives. Our engagement rings, diamond jewelry and attention to customer care are now enjoyed internationally. For questions, don’t hesitate to call us at (716) 631-1584 during business hours or use our convenient online contact form to reach out.

Choose your center stone:
Pear
Pear
Marquise
Marquise
Emerald
Emerald
Round
Round
Oval
Oval
Radiant
Radiant
Princess
Princess
Cushion
Cushion

Buy now, pay later.

Financing Options

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should I buy my engagement ring from Ben Garelick?

Ben Garelick has been a trusted family-owned jeweler since 1952, serving customers in Buffalo, NY and worldwide for over 70 years. Every diamond in our collection is hand-selected for outstanding cut quality, and our knowledgeable team takes the time to guide you through every decision, from choosing the right stone shape to finding the perfect setting. Whether you visit our Williamsville showroom or shop online, you'll receive the same personal, expert service we've built our reputation on.

What engagement ring designers do you carry?

We carry some of the most respected names in fine jewelry, including Simon G., Gabriel & Co., Noam Carver, Kirk Kara, Barkev's, Fana, and ArtCarved, alongside our own exclusive Ben Garelick designs. Each designer brings a distinct aesthetic, from classic solitaires to intricate vintage-inspired settings, giving you hundreds of unique styles to choose from in one place.

Do you offer lab-grown diamonds and alternative gemstones?

Yes. We offer a full range of options to suit every preference and budget. Our collection includes traditional mined diamonds, lab-grown diamonds, moissanite, and a variety of coloured gemstones including blue sapphire, pink sapphire, morganite, and more. Our team can walk you through the differences so you can make the choice that feels right for you.

Can I get a custom engagement ring designed?

Absolutely. Ben Garelick's artisan jewelers can hand craft a completely bespoke engagement ring to your exact specifications. Whether you have a clear vision or just a starting point, our team will work with you to bring it to life, from choosing your diamond or gemstone to designing every detail of the setting. Get in touch or visit us in store to start the conversation.