Why Buy Jewelry from Ben Garelick?

First opened in Buffalo, New York in 1952, Ben Garelick is a family owned business. Having learned the business starting as a stock boy, our current owner, Peter Manka Sr. and his children, Jennifer and Peter Jr. dedicate their efforts to offering high quality jewelry and great customer service. We have customers who have been coming to us over decades and generations, and we take their happiness and satisfaction personally.

Peter Sr. has passed down his hard won, practical experience and expertise. Together designers and products are selected for superior quality, style and, of utmost importance, sparkle. An extensive in store inventory with a wide variety of styles and prices is maintained for immediate purchase. Our relationships with our designers are strong, allowing us to offer excellent delivery times on special orders, and confidence when we work with our designers to customize pieces for our clients.

We maintain on-site cleaning and repair facilities with expert bench jewelers to ensure quality repairs.

Having maintained an online presence for over a decade, BenGarelick.com has melded the traditional local jewelry store with the modern world of e-commerce. We are dedicated to fulfilling our customer’s highest expectations, whether that customer is around the corner or around the world.

Don’t just take our word for it! We have been reviewed thousands of times by our customers on Google, Facebook, WeddingWire, TrustPilot, Yelp and other sites. Read our customer’s reviews. We hope you’ll be adding your review soon!

Ben Garelick Happily Married Couple

Free Gift Wrapping

Ben Garelick will gift wrap your purchase free of charge beautifully wrapped and tied with a luxurious blue ribbon. Boxes included on all orders.

Welcome Newcomer