Free Shipping on All Orders

No Sales Tax on Out of State Residents




Classic Diamond Engagement Rings

Why are celebs like Anne Hathaway, Reese Witherspoon, and Amy Adams opting for the simplicity and brilliance of a classic diamond engagement ring? Because they know that the classic styles will be IN style forever. Classic diamond engagement rings are made for you to enjoy for a lifetime and then pass down to the next generation. A round cut diamond is, by far, the most popular and lasting classic style, but the square princess cut and emerald cut diamonds are also loved. And Ben Garelick Jewelers has hundreds for you to choose from - both online and at their Buffalo, New York showroom.

Variety, Personalization, Quality, & More At Ben Garelick Jewelers

Ben Garelick offers hundreds of classic diamond engagement rings from exclusive designers Kirk Kara, Gabriel, Simon G, Barkev's, Coast, Vivadore, and our own Ben Garelick Line. This Royal Celebration Ring by Ben Garelick is one of our favorites while this Kirk Kara "Charlotte" combines a classic setting with the more contemporary diamond and blue sapphire combination. You set your classic diamond engagement ring in your choice of 14 or 18K gold. Nearly every style is available in white gold, yellow gold, rose gold or a combination. Palladium and platinum are also available in most styles.

At Ben Garelick you can personalize your engagement ring with your specially selected center stone, in any carat weight, any shape, and any gem. Whether a classic round diamond is your favorite, or you prefer a pear, oval, princess cut, or any other shape, Ben Garelick can personalize your engagement ring.

When you shop with your friends at Ben Garelick Jewelers, you can shop with confidence and the assurance that you will always have the best quality workmanship and materials, ethically sourced diamonds and a special sparkle! Every jewelry consultants at Ben Garelick is experienced and knowledgeable enough to walk you through every facet of buying a diamond. After all, our classic diamond engagement rings will last forever.

Trade Up At Ben Garelick Jewelers!

Buying from Ben Garelick means you are guaranteed the ability to trade up your diamond for as long as you own it. Our policy insures that you can change your center diamond any time by simply paying the difference. Or, with our 0% financing, you can get the perfect diamond ring that will last a lifetime! Don’t wait to symbolize your love with one of our classic diamond engagement rings in a style that will be perfect for her individual tastes and your budget. Chat live with our jewelry experts online and ask them any questions about any ring. Or stop by our Buffalo, New York jewelry store for an in-person consultation. Questions? Check out our FAQs or give us a call at (716) 631-1584.