FREE SHIPPING on orders over $50

Log In

Log In

Forgot Your Password?

Cart Subtotal: $0.00

Honora Santa Fe Coin Freshwater Pearl Stretch Bracelet.
Artcarved Solitude 14kt White Gold Twist Engagement Ring
Everlon 1/6 Carat Sterling Silver Diamond Everlon Knot Ring
Hearts On Fire Fulfillment Pendant 18Kt White Gold With 1.01 Carats Diamonds.
0.46 Carat Princess Diamond Stud Earrings in 14K White Gold
ELLE Sterling Silver Hammered Collection Medium Oval Hoop Earrings With Signature Ruby
0.25 Carats Diamond Channel Set 14K White Gold Diamond Wedding Ring.
Ben Garelick 14kt Chocolate and Yellow Gold 17 Inch Braided Necklace.
Hearts on Fire Convergence Pendant 18K White Gold With 0.95 Carats Diamonds on Adjustable 20 Inch Chain.
Le Vian 1.58 Carats Right Hand Ring Set With Chocolate and White Diamonds in 14K White Gold
0.30 Carats Diamond Channel Set 14kt White Gold Diamond Wedding Ring.
Le Vian 14K Yellow Gold Drop Earrings With 2.36 Carats Chocolate and White Diamonds

What Sparkles Most Is YOU

Check out FireMark Princess Cut Diamonds

» Check out FireMark Princess Cut Diamonds

The Prettiest Diamonds: Exclusive Cuts

Ben Garelick Jewelers carries the prettiest diamonds in Buffalo NY with exclusive cuts by Hearts on Fire and FireMark. Hearts on Fire are the world’s most perfectly cut diamonds and reflect the most light out of any other diamond in the world. You will see all the colors of the rainbow in every Hearts on Fire diamond. FireMark Princess Cut Diamonds are averaging the same if not more light return than ideal cut round diamonds. You’ve got to see these diamonds for yourself!

Blue Sapphires

Check out Hearts on Fire

Everyday: Diamonds Galore

With diamond shapes including round, princess, heart, Asscher, Emerald, Radiant and Cushion we are sure to have the diamond of your dreams. We will also love selling 2 carat and 3 carat diamonds. We also carry Ben Garelick Appraised diamonds as well as EGL, AGS and GIA certified diamonds.

Why shop at Ben Garelick?

Want to see the prettiest diamond engagement ring selection in Buffalo? How about a shimmering 2-carat, brilliant-cut diamond to revive and transform your heirloom diamond ring? Just had a baby and need a push present that will delight your lovely wife? Then come right in. Ben Garelick Jewelers will bring your fine jewelry dreams alive with glimmering diamonds, sapphires, rubies and pearls, with settings in gold, white-gold, platinum and palladium. Our glamorous diamond rings, diamond earrings, diamond pendants and diamond bracelets will make you sparkle.

For over 50 years Ben Garelick Jewelers has shared in your engagement, wedding, anniversary and birthday celebrations with our quality jewelry. We’ve earned our reputation for reliability and consistency and are proud to be Buffalo’s exclusive dealer of Hearts on Fire, with their loose diamonds and diamond rings of extraordinary craftsmanship. We also carry fine luxury and couture jewelry from designers such as Simon G., Kirk Kara, A. Jaffe, FireMark and Le Vian. Our diamond selection includes a wide variety of colors, from white to pink to yellow to chocolate. Whether it is an ideal-cut, 3-carat diamond, or a dazzling ring of chocolate diamonds set in strawberry gold, you’ll find your heart’s desire at Ben Garelick Jewelers.

We invite you to select from these many wonderful choices of beautiful gems and fine diamond jewelry in our spacious new showroom on Transit Road in Williamsville. Our specially-trained staff will give you our best personal attention, and every item is clearly marked with its price so you’ll know immediately that you are getting the best value possible. You deserve it, because what sparkles most is you.